I’m equal parts delighted and horrified when some dark corner of the internet breaks out of containment and into the mainstream, which is exactly what happened a few weekends back when Finn Wolfhard portrayed a “looksmaxxing gigachad” on SNL.
Definitely has flavours of the Tumblr pro-ana era, especially with it's targeting of newly self-conscious (as in, literally newly conscious of themselves as observable beings) preteens.
Had too google that but 100$, definitely analogous. Adults can barely use social media well, I think we're still a long way off from figuring out healthy ways for kids to use it.
the phrenology comparison is the sharpest thing i've seen written about looksmaxxing. mandibular angles and zygomatic arches dropped like they're maxillofacial surgeons on a coffee break - and underneath it's the same pseudoscientific skull-measuring dressed up in a new vocabulary. a nineteen-year-old hitting his own jaw with a hammer to cause microfractures he claims heal in a jawline-enhancing way, taking artificial hormones, and using meth. and calling that ascension. the caveat about not knowing how to talk about figures like clavicular because he's nineteen is honest and necessary - you had the judgment of a smarter-than-average goldfish at that age too. but the platform size changes the calculus. the suspicion that looksmaxxing is the natural end of instagram optimization culture feels right - women experienced heightened anxiety and depression and disordered eating first and this is the spiritual male sibling of that phenomenon. gilded crap is still crap. healthy community as antidote to toxic community is the only intervention that actually scales.
I'm glad it resonated! You're right to call out the platform size—it's absolutely a difference maker, although I'm still finding my way re: how to talk about (and them!)
nothing to really share here, just disheartened at this phenomenon. as someone who's not a man it is frustrating seeing a lot of people in pain who never in a thousand years would let you help them, and whose grasp on reality is so loose they might as well be floating through the atmosphere. it seems to me their entire philosophy of life is distorted: they believe they'll get laid more if they're "hot" and they want to get laid more because they think that'll bring them happiness, when i can attest to sex not being able to fill pretty much any void. then again, it's hard to change an entire community's worldview, especially when you're sort of the demographic they blame for their problems. thank you for the piece either way! i think it's good for people who aren't as online to know about this. it concerns all of us.
I agree, it's deeply troubling. People--men, women, and anybody else--strike me as belonging- and validation-seeking creatures. Through that lenses, I'm not surprised how this particular movement has grown. Also I tend to agree, other men have the most immediate responsibility (and best chance) of pushing back on this worldview.
I think you are just overcomplicating matters. Also, looksmaxxing has nothing (directly) to do with getting in relationships. It is about casual sex because, ultimately, a man who cannot get regular casual sex cannot have equal relationships (and thus, good relationships) with women. Also, men just like to have sex with women in general. How can there be an equal relationship when one person is vastly more replaceable than the other? The answer is that you can't.
Young men are just reacting rationally to the material conditions of their lives. As the value of male sexual attraction has plummeted (because the supply has increased thanks to things like online dating and the overall cultural changes which removed rules which might have inhibited female behavior), that means men must compete harder and harder for access to sex. So, is it any surprise that... they do things which make them more competitive on the marketplace?
It is no different in how jobs that 50 years ago didn't really require any sort of credentials now require college degrees. Removal of regulation plus an increase in the supply of labor means employers can be pickier.
"I don’t have the answers for how we put the genie back into the bottle, but I do believe that healthy community is the best antidote to toxic community"
You aren't going to change anyone's behavior unless you can find a way to help men get regular casual sex with women. No amount of handwringing about toxicity will make anyone change their mind.
Ultimately, you're competing against a process which CAN work, so, you or anyone else who wants men to behave differently will have to offer an alternative that also works, preferably better.
There's a lot going on here, and I'm not 100% certain I follow it all, but I disagree that it's a rational reaction. Self-improvement intellectually, socially, and--yes--aesthetically, can be a great thing. Looksmaxxing, in my eyes ,crosses over into something toxic for a number of the reasons I listed above.
I strongly disagree that "regular casual sex" is the solution here either, although I would like to see more men in healthy relationships, whether that's a committed monogamous version or a series of respectful, casual encounters, BUT getting those relationships isn't the solution, it's downstream of fixes men need to make in their inner lives. Relationships (serious and casual) aren't things you can prescribe to people like an antibiotic.
I've seen no evidence that looksmaxxing works in a consistent, healthy way either, and I do believe that the approach to life that I'm arguing for works better.
You may not think the solution is casual sex, but for looksmaxxers, that is the solution they want. You can disagree that their lack of it is a problem, but, ultimately, these people believe the lack of it IS a problem and will behave accordingly. If you want to convince them to behave differently, you'll need to convince them to change their goals (And I have beachfront properties in Kansas to sell you if you think you can stop men from wanting to sleep with women) or convince them you have a better/easier way to achieve their goals.
"I strongly disagree that "regular casual sex" is the solution here either, although I would like to see more men in healthy relationships"
As I said, ultimately any improvement in their relationships is not really a goal of looksmaxxers as a whole. They don't generally want relationships, and, can you really blame them? Why would they, when any relationship they have with a woman is going to have an enormous power imbalance in the woman's favor? That is not a healthy way to have a relationship.
"I've seen no evidence that looksmaxxing works in a consistent, healthy way either, and I do believe that the approach to life that I'm arguing for works better."
For casual sex, it absolutely CAN work. It's not guaranteed, of course, because ultimately your genetics set a hard limit on your sexual attractiveness to women and for some men, they will never meet the bar required to elicit genuine sexual attraction from women.
Can I ask how you'd describe yourself? Whether that's politically, socially, or as part of any community online or in real life, or really any way you want to? No worries if not, and I'm not trying to "gotcha" you or anything, but some of the things you're saying sketch a world view about people, biology, and psychology that seems pretty different than what I see and encounter in my own day-to-day, and I think it would help me understand it a little better if I had a sense of who I'm talking to and how they see themselves and the world around them.
Definitely has flavours of the Tumblr pro-ana era, especially with it's targeting of newly self-conscious (as in, literally newly conscious of themselves as observable beings) preteens.
Had too google that but 100$, definitely analogous. Adults can barely use social media well, I think we're still a long way off from figuring out healthy ways for kids to use it.
100%*
the phrenology comparison is the sharpest thing i've seen written about looksmaxxing. mandibular angles and zygomatic arches dropped like they're maxillofacial surgeons on a coffee break - and underneath it's the same pseudoscientific skull-measuring dressed up in a new vocabulary. a nineteen-year-old hitting his own jaw with a hammer to cause microfractures he claims heal in a jawline-enhancing way, taking artificial hormones, and using meth. and calling that ascension. the caveat about not knowing how to talk about figures like clavicular because he's nineteen is honest and necessary - you had the judgment of a smarter-than-average goldfish at that age too. but the platform size changes the calculus. the suspicion that looksmaxxing is the natural end of instagram optimization culture feels right - women experienced heightened anxiety and depression and disordered eating first and this is the spiritual male sibling of that phenomenon. gilded crap is still crap. healthy community as antidote to toxic community is the only intervention that actually scales.
I'm glad it resonated! You're right to call out the platform size—it's absolutely a difference maker, although I'm still finding my way re: how to talk about (and them!)
nothing to really share here, just disheartened at this phenomenon. as someone who's not a man it is frustrating seeing a lot of people in pain who never in a thousand years would let you help them, and whose grasp on reality is so loose they might as well be floating through the atmosphere. it seems to me their entire philosophy of life is distorted: they believe they'll get laid more if they're "hot" and they want to get laid more because they think that'll bring them happiness, when i can attest to sex not being able to fill pretty much any void. then again, it's hard to change an entire community's worldview, especially when you're sort of the demographic they blame for their problems. thank you for the piece either way! i think it's good for people who aren't as online to know about this. it concerns all of us.
I agree, it's deeply troubling. People--men, women, and anybody else--strike me as belonging- and validation-seeking creatures. Through that lenses, I'm not surprised how this particular movement has grown. Also I tend to agree, other men have the most immediate responsibility (and best chance) of pushing back on this worldview.
I think you are just overcomplicating matters. Also, looksmaxxing has nothing (directly) to do with getting in relationships. It is about casual sex because, ultimately, a man who cannot get regular casual sex cannot have equal relationships (and thus, good relationships) with women. Also, men just like to have sex with women in general. How can there be an equal relationship when one person is vastly more replaceable than the other? The answer is that you can't.
Young men are just reacting rationally to the material conditions of their lives. As the value of male sexual attraction has plummeted (because the supply has increased thanks to things like online dating and the overall cultural changes which removed rules which might have inhibited female behavior), that means men must compete harder and harder for access to sex. So, is it any surprise that... they do things which make them more competitive on the marketplace?
It is no different in how jobs that 50 years ago didn't really require any sort of credentials now require college degrees. Removal of regulation plus an increase in the supply of labor means employers can be pickier.
"I don’t have the answers for how we put the genie back into the bottle, but I do believe that healthy community is the best antidote to toxic community"
You aren't going to change anyone's behavior unless you can find a way to help men get regular casual sex with women. No amount of handwringing about toxicity will make anyone change their mind.
Ultimately, you're competing against a process which CAN work, so, you or anyone else who wants men to behave differently will have to offer an alternative that also works, preferably better.
I appreciate you chiming in.
There's a lot going on here, and I'm not 100% certain I follow it all, but I disagree that it's a rational reaction. Self-improvement intellectually, socially, and--yes--aesthetically, can be a great thing. Looksmaxxing, in my eyes ,crosses over into something toxic for a number of the reasons I listed above.
I strongly disagree that "regular casual sex" is the solution here either, although I would like to see more men in healthy relationships, whether that's a committed monogamous version or a series of respectful, casual encounters, BUT getting those relationships isn't the solution, it's downstream of fixes men need to make in their inner lives. Relationships (serious and casual) aren't things you can prescribe to people like an antibiotic.
I've seen no evidence that looksmaxxing works in a consistent, healthy way either, and I do believe that the approach to life that I'm arguing for works better.
You may not think the solution is casual sex, but for looksmaxxers, that is the solution they want. You can disagree that their lack of it is a problem, but, ultimately, these people believe the lack of it IS a problem and will behave accordingly. If you want to convince them to behave differently, you'll need to convince them to change their goals (And I have beachfront properties in Kansas to sell you if you think you can stop men from wanting to sleep with women) or convince them you have a better/easier way to achieve their goals.
"I strongly disagree that "regular casual sex" is the solution here either, although I would like to see more men in healthy relationships"
As I said, ultimately any improvement in their relationships is not really a goal of looksmaxxers as a whole. They don't generally want relationships, and, can you really blame them? Why would they, when any relationship they have with a woman is going to have an enormous power imbalance in the woman's favor? That is not a healthy way to have a relationship.
"I've seen no evidence that looksmaxxing works in a consistent, healthy way either, and I do believe that the approach to life that I'm arguing for works better."
For casual sex, it absolutely CAN work. It's not guaranteed, of course, because ultimately your genetics set a hard limit on your sexual attractiveness to women and for some men, they will never meet the bar required to elicit genuine sexual attraction from women.
Can I ask how you'd describe yourself? Whether that's politically, socially, or as part of any community online or in real life, or really any way you want to? No worries if not, and I'm not trying to "gotcha" you or anything, but some of the things you're saying sketch a world view about people, biology, and psychology that seems pretty different than what I see and encounter in my own day-to-day, and I think it would help me understand it a little better if I had a sense of who I'm talking to and how they see themselves and the world around them.
Does it really matter who I am? I believe what I have told you is correct as far as I can tell.