You’ve heard the phrase “it takes a village” before, probably in the context of what’s required to raise a child. That bringing up little ones is immensely difficult goes without saying, but there are broader applications of the expression worth examining.1
Human beings, with some rare exceptions, are communal creatures. We work best in packs, both for purposes of productivity and for matters of the soul. We’ve relied on groups throughout history, primarily in the form of family. Well, families beget villages, which beget nations, which beget the world we live in—flawed though it may be. Today, our “villages” typically represent the network of relationships we have in the communities to which we belong.
Unfortunately, something is rotten within our villages. More and more we find ourselves distanced from family and friends. There’s probably no single explanation for it, but we’ve all heard some of the theories. Call it tech-driven social isolation, call it the male loneliness epidemic, call it our fractured politics, call it the loss of our shared values, or call it whatever else you want—my conclusion is the same. Our villages are not as strong as we need them to be. Worse, some people don’t feel they have villages at all.
These problems have given rise to a new expression floating around, “everyone wants a village, but nobody wants to be a villager.”2
The meaning is clear—all of us like the benefits of communal support, but when it’s our turn to provide support we shirk back from our duties. Economists call this the “free-rider problem.” Normal people call it being a taker. Destiny’s Child called it being a scrub.3 Terminology aside, I suspect you are not an isolation-seeking hermit and would like to both benefit from and contribute to a village, even if your personal village feels dilapidated and in dire need of repair. I’m here to tell you that you can build the village you want by being the villager others need.
I’ve learned this from personal experience. My nuclear family has never been particularly stable, I felt isolated for most of my teens, and I spent my early 20s emulating all the wrong traits, in order to become a person I didn’t actually want to be, and so found myself underserving in and underserved by my relationships. But somehow, with a lot of work, luck, and generosity from my friends, things got better.
Thanks to those years of wandering, I know what it’s like to lack a village, which is why I’m so grateful today to be surrounded by a cohort of family (blood and found) and friends, who enrich my life in a way younger me could never have imagined. If there’s hope for someone as lost as I’ve been, then there’s hope for all of us. Becoming a better villager is within your power and the best way I know of to contribute to the healing of this flawed world.
“Build It And They Will Come”
Being the best villager you can be to others is the best way to receive from your village in the long run, so here are some roughly structured and generally unprioritized ideas on what makes a good villager and how you can be one. My format is borrowed from Susan Sontag.4
The essence of being a good villager is making the lives of the people in your village more peaceful, joyful, and abundant. This is true on their best days and doubly true during their hard times.
Supporting your villagers is a frame—a way of looking at your world and the people in it—that you must cultivate. We’re all selfish to some degree, but conscientiousness and charity are learnable skills. Push yourself to recognize the gaps in the lives of your villagers, then do your utmost to fill them. Better still if you can identify their needs before they know they need them.
Of course, you can’t force someone into your village, but you can invite them in while they’re still on the outside. Take the responsibility in a relationship to progress it. That may be getting drinks with a colleague after work or checking in on a friend you haven’t seen in a while. Be honest with people; tell them how much you value them and how lucky you feel that they are part of your life. Sappy though it sounds, people respond to genuine affection, because they can tell it comes from the heart.
Good villagers don’t manage their relationships like a checkbook. You don’t do a favor for someone because you expect them to return it the next day, month, or year. I’d argue you shouldn’t even worry about it all balancing out in the end, but rather should do good unto others because that’s being the person in the village that you want to be.
It’s also healthy not to treat your relationships like a checkbook because they won’t balance. People will be distant, invites you extend will not be returned, and when you ask for help you’ll sometimes get a no. So if you find yourself frustrated with your villagers, forgive them. Assume good intent on their behalf, recognizing that they are flawed people in a mean world, and won’t always be able to show up.
By this, I’m telling you that relationships will never be 50-50. Sometimes someone in your village can only give 30 and you have to give 70. Sometimes you’re only capable of 60, so a gap will exist. That’s okay—relationships cannot be maximal at all times. Be gentle with yourself and forgiving of the gaps, trusting that things will work out in the end between people who mean well.
Gaps, however, do not excuse consistent toxicity in a relationship. There’s a reason the Athenians practiced exile, and if you’re pouring your energy and service into someone who doesn’t wish for your personal good or is consistently taking advantage of you, consider whether you’re not better off focusing your efforts as a villager on others. You deserve to be treated well too.
Being a villager is difficult, after all. You’re not a bad person because when your friend asks for a favor there’s a small voice in your head that says “no, I’d really rather stay at home on the couch.” We all have those voices inside us, telling us to take the easy way out, and that’s okay. Maturing is learning to acknowledge those voices and then refusing to take their advice, because when you stop to listen, the better angels of your nature have already told you what to do.
Remember that it’s okay to be intentional about building your village. Scratch that, it is noble to be intentional about building your village. For years, I struggled with the belief that strong relationships were things that other people had that I couldn’t, because if I tried intentionally to build strong relationships it would be somehow dirty or dishonest because I was “faking” it by virtue of desiring it. But most good people aren’t born good in my experience, rather they want to do good things and from there come, eventually, to embody their actions. And wanting strong relationships is a great thing when those relationships are built on a foundation of mutual respect, service, and—most importantly—love.
Thus, the first and simplest step is to love the people in your village, even if you sometimes don’t like them. All the rest stems from that love. Philosophers, religious leaders, and dating-lamenters have debated the meaning of love forever, so I’ll let you superimpose your personal definition here. For what it’s worth, I think the world would be a lot better if we loved more freely and expressed it more easily.
The second and most practical way to be a good villager is to provide consistent and generous acts of service. Strangely, this is harder than it used to be, especially for larger requests. I worry we’ve fallen away from asking for significant things from our village in our joint efforts not to impose on others and to take up as little space as possible. To never be an inconvenience, to never ask for more than another is readily willing to give, and to never request something without the guarantee of a positive reception are all examples of this trend. But one can ask without being greedy, and another can reject without being callous.
Great villagers move beyond asking if their people need help, though. Instead they freely and enthusiastically give their help without waiting for the ask. “Do you need any help with the move?” is a fine question, but “I’d love to help with the move, would it be more useful to come pack before or show up day-of?” is going to get a much better response. So pick your friends up from the airport, bring them cookies when they’re having a rough week, or just call them to check in once in a while. The services can be small or grand, what matters is that you consistently provide them.
A good village requires a carpenter and a blacksmith, because you wouldn’t ask your carpenter to make you a horseshoe. You don’t need to do everything for everyone to be a good villager; you need to advertise and offer what services you yourself are good at. My girlfriend and I love dogs, for example, and our friends often ask us to dog sit for them while they travel because it’s 1) something we’re good at, 2) we love to do it, and 3) we offer to do it loudly and frequently before they even need to ask.
You must do everything in your power to show up at the big events. Call it the Irish in me, but I’m loath to miss a wedding or a funeral. They are the life milestones for which people remember who shows up. I’m not suggesting you do it for extra credit, I’m telling you to do it because showing up is an act of care, and you will benefit in your relationships from providing that care. There’s plenty of other events like this, so throw in baptisms, bar mitzvahs, college graduations, or any other major celebrations to which you’re invited to as well.
Of course, this isn’t always easy. Although it’s joyous to be a part of others’ lives, friction can make it difficult, especially when we’re getting on planes to do it. You might think this is a no-brainer, but try turning 30 and getting yourself excited for your 24th wedding in two years. Trust me, it’s important to keep the right perspective when the going gets tough and show up to the big events with a smile on your face. Note too that it’s not sufficient just to show up at the big events, but if that isn’t apparent by now this essay probably isn’t for you.
Great villagers host things and you should be a convener within your village. Invite your friends over for a meal; it doesn’t have to be the full Martha Stewart experience—you can serve microwave pizza and juice boxes for all I care. Or, if wining and dining isn’t your thing, invite them to a movie. Whatever you do, what’s important is that you take some ownership in bringing the village together, not just waiting for things to come to you.
Don’t stop there though. Go beyond hosting discrete events and start regular activities or foster annual traditions. Maybe you and your friends kick up a book club, or perhaps you all commit to an annual Friendsgiving, or choose to gather every First Monday in May to split a bottle of champagne in the park. The big celebrations anchor our years, but we’re not limited to eleven Federal holidays—villages make their own traditions. You might find when life gets busy and kids, jobs, and other things get in the way, that these traditions are the basis on which you get back together with the people you love the most.
Also, just because your village is primarily social doesn’t mean you can’t consider it geographically and strive to make further improvements. After all, we live in physical places, in which the functions of our socializing often play out. Even if you’re a renter, I’d encourage you to adopt a sense of ownership over that place you call home. Pick up a few pieces of trash when you go out for a walk, return the grocery cart to where you got it, and generally look out for ways to make the spaces you live in better, safer, and more comfortable for everyone who shares in them. It’ll work for your village and help other villages too.
We tried a single-sex, same-age village. You might have heard of it. Does Lord of the Flies ring any bells? Successful villages are diverse. Even if you have friends across the gender spectrum, do you spend time with people outside your age group? Your friend’s suspiciously older situationship doesn’t count, that’s an NYC phenomenon. So find some old people at church and take them out to coffee, I promise you they have the best gossip. Or take your sister’s kids out for a long weekend, they’ll never forget it, and your sis will appreciate the help. This period of history is unique in terms of how little time we spend with people who aren’t our age—and that’s a dynamic worth resisting.
It’s also helpful to remember that your village is temporary. After all, you’re only here temporarily. More than that, the fact that someone isn’t in your life forever doesn’t mean the time you spend with each other isn’t noble and meaningful. Maybe your job is sending you overseas for two years—don’t neglect building relationships just because you know you won’t be there forever. None of us are here forever, so whether someone is in your village for a week or for decades, be helpful and inclusive.
I mentioned earlier how villages beget nations, which is true, but maybe not useful for thinking about society as a whole. I challenge you to make your village as big as possible, not just because it will enrich your life, but because although your village is yours alone, the people in it are also the center of their own villages. Showing up positively in their lives helps them show up better in the lives of others. In that way, your healthy village can be part of a constellation of relationships across society, villages chain-linked together in an effort to heal and be healed in a broken world.
Finally, being a good recipient in the village means more than accepting help when it’s offered to you, although plenty of you independent types need to get better at that too. The goal is to ask for help when you need it. It’s really, really hard—especially for those of us whose love language is to show up via acts of service, but would never dream of asking for service from others. I promise you, your relationships will be deeper and better, and your village will be healthier, if you raise your hand and say “I need help.”
I raised my hand and asked my village for help a few weeks ago when I started Pound Foolish and it has meant the world to me to see so many people share their support. I’m not sure if I count as a writer yet, but my aspiration to be one is deeply tied to my interest in being a villager. Anne Lamott explained this best in Bird by Bird:
Many of us can be soothed by writing: think of how many times you have opened a book, read one line, and said, “Yes!” And I want to give people that feeling, too, of connection, communion…It is one of the greatest feelings known to humans, the feeling of being the host, of hosting people, of being the person to whom they come for food and drink and company. This is what the writer has to offer.
I hope something here is useful for you, I hope you are a light in the lives of others, and most of all I hope that when you need it most, your village is there for you.
What ways do you like to be a villager? I’d love to hear about them directly or in the comments. See you Friday for the Weekend Read.
Interestingly, although the phrase has often been associated with African proverbs, research does not bear out a clear origin.
Others have been talking about this problem and a few pieces that I skimmed while collecting my own thoughts for this article include ones from Motherly, Betches, and Liberatory Imagination.
And personally, I do not want no scrub.
In her “Notes on ‘Camp’” and featured in last week’s Weekend Read in Notes on Taste.




Absolutely love this - one of the things that started to bother me about my own village cultivation was that it seemed hard to maintain a high enough rate of 1:1 coffees/grab-a-drinks to make them not all catch-ups, so I've started inviting all my local villagers every week to the Thursday line dancing lesson hosted by a local bar, and I'm pleased to say it's achieved exactly what I hoped: low stakes, goofy, regularly occurring and a new mix of villagers each week
This is an extremely important post in this day and age. Easier to do this in suburban life than a city. You get back more than you give.