Amor Towles’ A Gentleman in Moscow is one of my favorite novels. Like many of my treasured books, I have abused its pages with scrawled notes, underlines, and dog-ears. Today, let’s talk about one passage I return to time and time again.
The titular Gentleman is Count Alexander Rostov. His romantic interest in the book is cinema darling Anna Urbanova. When Rostov meets Urbanova, he has recently been humbled—the Soviets have stripped him of his titles and his wealth and sentenced him to live out the remainder of his days confined to the Metropol Hotel.
We meet Urbanova, on the other hand, at her apogee. She has recently stormed the heights of Soviet cinema, wooing tastemakers and regular audiences alike with her portrayals of princesses and heroines. All the attendant trappings of wealth come along with her newfound fame and she absolutely puts them to use.
Thus, the Anna who sashays onto the page is charming and vain and kind and irresponsible all at once, so it isn’t a surprise when, after a brief assignation with our protagonist, she somewhat rudely dismisses him. After all, she is a perfect example of that temperamental young celebrity who continues to haunt Page Six with stories of on-set meltdowns to this day.
But fate can be fickle and artistic tastes change. Just Google “superhero fatigue” to see how much ink media types spill about what we do and don’t like to watch. Eventually, Soviet film moves on from Anna, and she loses everything that she had gained.
It’s here that Towles gets to the good stuff, positing that “when one experiences a profound setback in the course of an enviable life, one has a variety of options,” before suggesting that our protagonists, the Count and the Actress, choose to respond by joining “the Confederacy of the Humbled.”
He goes on to describe membership in this elite, unlucky fraternity as follows:
“The Confederacy of the Humbled is a close-knit brotherhood whose members travel with no outward markings, but who know each other at a glance. For having fallen suddenly from grace, those in the Confederacy share a certain perspective. Knowing beauty, influence, fame, and privilege to be borrowed rather than bestowed, they are not easily impressed. They are not quick to envy or take offense. They certainly do not scour the papers in search of their own names. They remain committed to living among their peers, but they greet adulation with caution, ambition with sympathy, and condescension with an inward smile.”
Sentenced to live and die in a single building, The Count carves out a new life for himself with dignity and purpose. The Actress, having tasted sweet heights and bitter lows, slowly works her way back towards the life of a working actress.
In particular, while her talent compounds, she enters her new life without the vanity that plagued her old one. As Towles puts it, Anna “as a member of the Confederacy of the Humbled…had become an actress who appeared on time, knew her lines, and never complained.” No more meltdowns for Page Six.
“The world breaks everyone and afterward many are strong at the broken places.”
Ernest Hemingway, A Farewell to Arms
I’ve thought about that phrase, Confederacy of the Humbled, quite a lot since I first encountered it. The line gave terminology to a sense I had felt about the world for a long while. Broadly speaking, I see two groups, those who have been humbled and those who haven’t been.
Maybe humbling comes in the form of a job loss, or a significant health diagnosis, or a bad breakup, or the passing of a loved one. Perhaps the humbling is entirely internal, and no one knows what you’re struggling with. Or it could be that the humbling comes about via external forces. After all, what’s cancel culture if not society and its levers ostracizing an individual for their transgressions, real or perceived?
Humbling can also come at different times for different people. What someone is forced to learn in their swaddling clothes, another might not learn until their hair has gone white.
Unfortunately, all this variety in timing and manner of humbling can leave some people empathetic in certain domains and cold in others.
But regardless of how a humbling comes about, and I won’t suggest any binding criteria, I think a loss of identity is probably the lowest common denominator in any situation. One day we see ourselves as one thing and the next day we are not. Until you have lived in two worlds, the one from before and the one after, it’s hard to understand just how significantly different they are.
That understanding paves the way for near-boundless empathy and compassion. It helps contextualize life’s petty annoyances like long lines at the coffee shop and rain on a previously sunny day as the very small matters they are. It enables the humbled to see the people around them not just as allies or inconveniences, but as unique human beings, with their own unique aspirations, aptitudes, and struggles.
To that end, it’s hard for the people who haven’t been humbled to understand just how rough the world can be. The humbled, on the other hand, have a good sense for life’s coarseness, and an easier time understanding each other, even if the circumstances of their challenges are wildly different. What’s important isn’t what specifically happened to them, but the fact that they can relate to others who have similarly had the rug pulled out from underneath them.
While I would never wish a humbling on anyone, I do know that humbling will come for us all, in time. Some people are born to it, some work their way towards it along a path paved by their own weakness and vanity, and many more find it unluckily waiting for them along the way. Furthermore, the humbling might come in the form of a direct effect on our person or touching someone we love.
By the way—secretly—I think you’re luckiest it affects you directly. I’m hypothesizing here, but what’s worse than getting a terminal cancer diagnosis? Your child receiving a terminal cancer diagnosis.
Assuming then that life will kick all of us in the teeth, some way and somehow, the question becomes how will we face that moment? Probably not gracefully, at least not to start.
Count Rostov and Anna kick, struggle, and scream. There’s a reason grief is supposed to have seven stages, after all. You tend to go down hard when you get punched in the face and it’s only natural to indulge in some self-pity while you wallow on the floor.
But the choice remains to pick ourselves up and be better than before. Further, we can choose to use our humblings to become more empathetic and compassionate than the people we used to be. This aspect, more than any other, frustrates me when I look at people in the world whose response to life’s difficult circumstances is to become callous and cold to others’ suffering.
The good news is that so long as we draw breath, it’s never too late to improve our circumstances. At any point, no matter how dark the day or deep the hole, the choice to join the Confederacy of the Humbled remains ours.
Thoreau said it best in Walden:
“It appears as if men had deliberately chosen the common mode of living because they preferred it to any other. Yet they honestly think there is no choice left. But alert and healthy natures remember that the sun rose clear. It is never too late to give up our prejudices.”
Thanks for tuning in. As always, if you love every word or if you think I’m the internet’s dumbest boy, feel free to let me know directly or in the comments. See you next time.


