Of all the libations gifted to us by the gods, no drink is more misunderstood than the humble martini. And yes, I do mean humble.
The martini is my favorite drink. The only thing I like more than a martini is two martinis. The only thing more dangerous than two martinis is five martinis.
One, two, and five, by the way, are the only discrete quantities of martini I will drink in a single night, for understandable reasons and with predictable consequences.
In fact, I consider myself a martini expert, not because I can explain to you the history behind the drink or what on earth a botanical is, but because I believe I understand the spirit of the martini.
Today, I would like to share that understanding with you.
A martini is not a fancy drink for fancy people, as the propagandists would have you believe. It is a cold cup of gin for people who hate themselves, but want to do so in a slightly more aesthetic fashion. It is, god willing, McDonald’s-like in its consistency. You should be able to order a martini at a grand old hotel bar in London, or from a shack on the side of a desert road, and still get more or less the same thing.
In fact, I’ve found the best martinis aren’t served in bars at all, but rather prepared at home by people over the age of 75 as a pre-dinner warmup. Make of that what you will, but much like the tides coming in and out, science cannot explain it.
A martini, at its core, is a fundamentally honest drink. It is bracing, it is direct, and you know what you are getting, even if you can’t conceive of what horrors you’ll be getting into afterwards.
The pomp and circumstance are everything around it, but never the drink itself. The drink is simple, and if not approachable per se, at least always willing to be approached.
What, alchemically then, counts as a martini? Again, it’s simple, if not always easy. Ice-cold gin (or colder, if you can get it), a portion of vermouth (dash, trace, and memory are all good words to use for the quantity there), and a garnish, either a twist of lemon or an olive.
You can and should aspire for all those elements to come together in any particular martini you order, but you must never make a stink about having it exactly your way, at least until you are old enough to collect social security, at which point you deserve to be curmudgeonly about preparation.
Remember, you have ordered a cold cup of practically-straight liquor, and untoward whining about particularities is ill-matched to the spirit of that act.
Because I’m a progressive, and aspire to be tolerant and inclusive, I will extend the martini umbrella to those who prefer vodka instead of gin, although I believe I deserve a tax write-off for doing so.
A dirty martini, I’m sorry to tell you, is not a real martini. I love a dirty martini, and it is an exceptional cocktail, but it is a fundamentally different thing. This is because the addition of brine clouds not only the cocktail, but the classic martini’s essential honesty.
An espresso martini, a lemon drop martini, or any other cocktail you might care to think of for which the suffix “-tini” has been applied at the end, is also not a martini. I am sure that position does not surprise you if you’ve read down this far.
Who makes these arbitrary rules? Me. I do. God chose me for this task and me alone. But please know I don’t draw lines here with any ill will or malice aforethought. As previously stated, I adore a dirty martini, and I’m happy for drinkers of all stripes to keep martini in the name of their beverage of choice, although if you’re an espresso martini fan I really recommend giving the carajillo a spin.
They’re just not the same.
Ultimately, a martini knows what it is, and you should too.
It’s properly enjoyed by oneself or with close friends, ideally while gossiping. It may be consumed alongside the bar or sitting at the table, but never on the go. It is always appreciated, yet, paradoxically, also often regretted. No matter, it is still perpetually looked forward to.
Somehow, that contradiction is where the magic happens.
My favorite martinis
Like I said, I actually think the best martinis are made at home and enjoyed without fuss, but I love a bar martini too. Again, anywhere should be able to make a great martini. These just happen to be places I consistently enjoy. Please note I don’t mean their house martini, either. I mean a plain, humble martini.
Queen Mary Tavern, Chicago
Long Island Bar, NYC
The Hotel Chelsea, NYC
The Campbell, NYC
Millwright’s, Connecticut
Martiny’s, NYC
Duke’s, London
And, most importantly, the next one
Again, this is just my list, and trust me—there are countless others I’ve enjoyed. If you feel so quaked, please do share your favorites with me.
Additional unsolicited martini advice
If you’re making a martini at home, keep both your gin and your glass in the freezer
I do not believe in ordering martinis “dry” or “wet” because I don’t believe bartenders actually make them differently and if you really care, I think you’re misunderstanding the first principles here
That said, dry
A martini is better stirred, a dirty martini is better shaken, and if you kept the gin in the freezer like I told you to then you don’t have to do either
It cuts down on back-and-forth to share a gin preference at the start, but any london dry gin will do, and if you’re fussy about it then you’re doing it wrong
A martini will taste better in direct proportion to the affection or the distaste you have for your drinking companion, i.e. it is a beverage to be shared with your closest allies or your worst enemies
Caveat emptor, I have never been proud of my performance after having a martini on an empty stomach
Godspeed and good health, I’m singing off now to find one, and I’ll raise it to your health.




Lobby bar is elite. Stop by at Cannaught if you find yourself in London anytime soon.
Queen Mary💯💯