6 Comments
User's avatar
Kash's avatar

so curious to see people are converting into Catholicism, especially across the US. where i live in Spain it's fairly common, but not so much in North America. i'll give the article you linked a read, but i'm curious about your conversion, if i may ask. is it because of your Irish ascendence, an epiphany you had, something else?

Marston Quinn's avatar

I’m going to write about it more at some point but very TLDR is that I grew up in a split Protestant Catholic household and eventually wandered from one side to the other, with a lot of meandering along the way.

Re: conversions, there are so many factors, but one suspicion I have is that the mainline Protestant denominations that dominated the US for most of its first two hundred of years have really withered as culture gets more secular.

Addie Curley's avatar

As a self-described 'recovering Catholic' who was born and raised in the church but abandoned it in undergrad, I've been feeling a pull back towards the ritual and community of the church, but still struggle with the RCC as an institution. I was predominantly raised in a Jesuit tradition, which I still admire, and was a big fan of Pope Francis's focus on social justice (Pope Leo seems to be continuing his work so far!) but haven't found a way to rectify my misgivings about how women and the LGBTQ community are treated (which comes intertwined with specific personal experiences from my earlier years). I really enjoyed the NYT article, as it gave me much to mull over and I might check out mass times in my area this week to see if there's a real pull or just nostalgia bubbling to the surface.

(So, yes, you have got a smidge of Catholicism on me. Or perhaps uncovered a dollop that was still there.)

Addie Curley's avatar

*since I can't edit my comment, 'reconcile' was what I meant, not 'rectify'.

Marston Quinn's avatar

This resonates a lot. Frankly, the biggest barrier I had to joining over several years was the misalignment between the Church and my stance on LGBTQ issues. I’m straight, but so many of my close friends and family aren’t that it felt like I would be betraying them. Engaging with Fr. Jim Martin’s work on that front and finding an incredible Jesuit church with an emphasis on inclusion was what finally got me over the hump, but it was a really challenging evolution for me. I might write more specifically about the whole thing at another time, but I just wanted to chime in with that and also to say that no one’s problems with the Church (from inside or outside) ever bother me. It’s a flawed institution that has caused a lot of harm. I’d just like to do what I can to make it better, especially as it gives so much to me.

Addie Curley's avatar

I really like Fr. Martin! And what I appreciate the most about the Jesuits is that they encourage asking questions, not just taking things at face value. It makes it much easier to engage with Scripture when you aren't faced with the 'because I said it's so' approach to church teachings. I would be really interested to read about your path to Catholicism and how you've worked through some of those barriers!