5 Comments
User's avatar
Kay's avatar

as someone who lives under a rock when it comes to bookish culture i greatly appreciate the roundups! the straight guys watching heated rivalry (a book ive never heard of) definitely seems like a fun rabbit hole I'll have to go down.

also makes me want to explore more of the bookstagram etc pages and try and support ones that are more to my taste!

Marston Quinn's avatar

I think it's a cool community - and although I was skeptical about it initially, I've come around to the idea that if it's helping people get into reading, then it's on my side.

Kay's avatar

yeah, definitely. like on one hand i have skepticism about the "as long as they're reading" idea as I'm not certain (though I'm willing to be convinced) any reading is inherently good or conveys equal benefits, e.g. the adults who read exclusively YA phenomenon. but from a practical perspective if it keeps bookstores in business and provides more entry points into reading then yeah, i can call it a good thing.

Marston Quinn's avatar

Forgive me if this sounds wonky, I'm brainstorming it in real time because maybe I'll do a write up or a video on it as some point, but I think my argument for "as long as they're reading" would basically be that in almost no circumstances so I think that someone choosing between reading and another form of leisure is choosing a better form of leisure than reading. Like, on net, I think someone is better off reading Percy Jackson and the Olympians than watching Breaking Bad, even if the latter is considered a greater form of art. That's not to say once we read we shouldn't try to pick up broader and more challenging reads, only that getting onto the track of readership vs. not reading at all is the hurdle I want people to overcome!

Kay's avatar

that makes sense! i’d definitely be interested in a post or video or something with your reasoning - to name just one argumant i’m sure the benefits of the sustained attention (even if it's on PJO) are probably unique & convey benefits even if the reading never moves beyond that. honestly i am even aware that even my personal disinterest in certain genres risks perpetuating snobbishness that prevents people from reading at all so it can be delicate trying to consider this topic without sounding gatekeepery.

and ofc i realise that the discourse around reading is arguably pointless, or unproductive, when it's enough of a task to get people, especially men, reading at all. it does seem silly to be picky and discourage people bc for sure, the best book is one that you actually read.