In 2019 I collapsed on a sidewalk in Boystown, Chicago.1 Because I happened to fall forwards, my chin took the brunt of the impact, shattering my jaw in two places, killing a tooth or two, and saving my life.
Had I fallen backwards, directly onto my skull from my manly and majestic height of 6’1”, I very easily could have expired just outside a bar named Scarlet, perhaps becoming some sort of neighborhood cautionary tale in the process. Instead, surgery, several months of a wired jaw, and an accompanying liquid diet left me with a brand new face and a renewed appreciation for the food we eat—not to mention a newfound awareness of the fact that any of us could go at any moment.
It’s partially because of my brush with la mort, and partially because of my love for food, that I find the concept of “last meals” so interesting.
The tradition of feeding the condemned a final meal has a long history, from the opulent feasts held for Roman gladiators the night before a bout, to Jesus Christ managing to assemble twelve adult friends for a group dinner we now call The Last Supper. No word on if they split the check or if one person put a card down and the rest Venmo-ed.
More recently in the United States, our contemporary fascination with last meals is inextricably tied up with our twisted system of capital punishment, and the final repasts of serial killers, terrorists, and the wrongfully convicted alike have been scrutinized and recreated over the years.
But you don’t need to be awaiting the hangman to indulge in the thought exercise, and I’m guessing most of us have had to come up with some semblance of a final menu in response to a friend’s gentle questioning or, god forbid, a corporate icebreaker.
And we’re not alone. One of the most popular stops on the celebrity PR circuit today is the Last Meals series on the YouTube channel Mythical Kitchen. Over one hundred celebrities have eaten through publicist-approved menus while pitching their latest projects.2
My problem with a celebrity’s PR menu, or even the one you trot out to impress your new coworkers at 8:45am on a Tuesday, is not only that they’re often impossibly complicated, but that they feel more designed to demonstrate good taste than actually produce a blueprint for an achievable meal you might go out and enjoy.
Now, there are no bad answers in a brainstorm, nor is there anything inherently wrong with flaunting your culinary expertise, but I’d like to recommend you treat your “last meal” a little more practically. In fact, I’d like you to figure out some semblance of what an attainable last meal is for you, and then go out and eat it at least once a year, hopefully with those you love most.
Because tomorrow is never guaranteed, and I don’t know how much time you’ve spent around individuals in ICUs or those receiving palliative care, but they’re not typically known for their healthy appetites. Better we indulge ourselves (responsibly) while we still can.
After all, it can be tempting to leave the good china in storage for the right occasion, or save that reservation you’ve been eyeing until after you accomplish the next big milestone, but what if we collectively decided any given day could be worthy of such celebration?
I wish nothing but good health and long life for you and yours, but I’d be lying if I didn’t tell you that you should also spend some time considering your own finitude. Many of us are already in the back nine, if not in our own right, then for those we love. For example, if you’ve graduated from high school and are lucky enough to still have your parents, you’re probably living out the last 5% of the time you’ll ever spend with them.
So figure out your favorite meal, and then go eat it enough that you get sick of it, then find a new last meal. There’s lots out there to experience and enjoy, and vanishingly little time to do it in.
And although no one is asking, here’s my “last meal.” The best approximation of it I’ve cobbled together in one meal was from Le Bouchon in Chicago. Sit at the bar if you can.
Gin martini with a twist
A dozen oysters, hold the mignonette
Salade Lyonnaise
A bottle of Beaujolais
Steak Frites with au poivre sauce
A slice of Guinness chocolate cake
A double pour of bourbon to toast the Devil bonne nuit
If you’ve got a go-to last meal answer, I’d love to hear about it in the comments below.
Thanks for tuning in. As always, whether you love every word or you think I’m the internet’s dumbest boy, I’d love to hear from you directly or in the comments. If you’d like to join our book club, check out Reading Fools over on Bindery. And, if you’d like to (anonymously) ask a question for me to answer à la advice columns, submit it here. See you next time.
There are those who would rebrand Boystown to the more inclusive and less pithy “Northalsted.” I respect anyone’s choice to call the neighborhood what they will, but having shed my blood on its pavement, I believe in my right to refer to it with its historical name.
Re: “media-trained,” the trick for a celebrity is to have a menu aspirational enough that we want to be you (sushi from Nobu, a cheeseburger from Four Charles) with just enough items relatable enough that we don’t resent you (mom’s casserole, a Diet Coke specifically from McDonald’s).





Relatedly - while still a bit PR-filtered I'm sure, the Off Menu podcast with James Acaster and Ed Gamble is a fantastic dive into celebrities' 'dream menus', which encourages them to dig into the old memory jar and pull out their favourite starter, main course, side dish, dessert, and drink (not in that order), which often leads to very specific dishes tied to specific memories (i.e. the macaroni and cheese my mom made me for dinner every day in second grade). It's a lovely display of how food and memory are so intertwined and even if those particular dishes can never be had again in that particular way, it's a celebration of a life well lived through the food they've eaten and the people they've shared it with. (Except for Robert De Niro, who just said 'whatever's good [on the menu]' for Every. Single. Dish.)